How Truck Accidents Differ from Car Accidents in South Carolina
Quick Summary: Truck accident claims in South Carolina can involve more potential defendants, higher insurance requirements for some carriers, and federal safety records that do not exist in an ordinary car case. Federal rules govern driving hours, testing, cargo, and other parts of commercial trucking. Some hours-of-service records only have to be retained for six months.
Key Takeaways
- South Carolina permits direct negligence claims against a trucking company even if it admits vicarious liability for the driver.
- In May 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court held federal law did not preempt the negligent-hiring claim against the broker in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II. It did not decide whether the broker was negligent.
- South Carolina requires at least $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident in bodily-injury coverage. Certain interstate freight carriers need at least $750,000.
- Required duty-status records and supporting documents generally must be kept for at least six months.
- An out-of-state truck does not automatically put a South Carolina case in federal court.
If a tractor-trailer hit you on I-20, I-26, or I-77, the claim may involve much more than the driver who caused the crash. The trucking company may also be involved, and depending on what happened, there may be questions about a broker, cargo company, maintenance provider, or another business connected to the truck.
IIHS large truck data shows that 96% of vehicle occupants killed in two-vehicle crashes involving a large truck and a passenger vehicle in 2024 were in the passenger vehicle. Truck accident claims can also involve federal trucking rules, electronic driving records, post-crash testing, and commercial insurance coverage that would not normally come up after a car accident.
That is why these claims need to be looked at differently from the start. You need to know who may be responsible, what insurance is available, which records need to be preserved, and whether federal trucking rules apply. This article explains those differences and what they can mean for a South Carolina truck accident claim.
How Are Truck Accident Claims Different From Car Accident Claims?
The biggest differences are the possible defendants, the insurance that may apply, and the evidence used to prove fault. A truck crash may involve several businesses, while federal safety rules create records that do not exist in a typical passenger-vehicle case.
What changes | Car accident claim | Truck accident claim |
Who may be responsible | Usually the other driver and vehicle owner | Driver and carrier; sometimes a broker, loader, or repair provider |
Minimum insurance | $25,000/$50,000 bodily injury plus $25,000 property damage | Certain interstate freight carriers: at least $750,000 |
Rules that may apply | State traffic and negligence law | State law plus federal motor-carrier rules |
Key evidence | Photos, collision report, witnesses, damage | Plus ELD, dispatch, driver, maintenance, and carrier records |
Court | Usually South Carolina Court of Common Pleas | State or federal court if removal requirements are met |
The Law Offices of Lori S. Murray handles motor-vehicle injury claims in Columbia, including commercial truck matters. In a truck case, identifying the operating carrier and the records it controls can be as important as identifying the driver.
Why Truck Crash Injuries Are Often More Serious
The standard federal maximum gross vehicle weight on the Interstate System is 80,000 pounds, subject to the bridge formula and other rules. IIHS reports that loaded tractor-trailers require 20% to 40% more stopping distance than cars.
That difference can mean longer medical treatment, more time away from work, and damages that are difficult to measure immediately after the crash. An early settlement figure may not reflect the full course of recovery.
Who Can Be Held Responsible for a Truck Crash in South Carolina?
In truck accident claims, the driver may not be the only defendant. Depending on the relationship and facts, a motor carrier may face vicarious liability for a driver’s conduct and separate claims based on its own hiring, training, supervision, maintenance, or entrustment decisions.
The Trucking Company May Be Liable for Its Own Conduct
A truck accident claim may involve more than the driver’s actions. In James v. Kelly Trucking Co., the South Carolina Supreme Court confirmed that a plaintiff may pursue claims against an employer for negligent hiring, training, supervision, or entrustment even when the company admits it is responsible for the driver’s negligence.
The separate claim still requires proof of the company’s own negligence. For example, negligent hiring can turn on whether the company knew or should have known that putting a particular driver on the road created an unreasonable risk.
Brokers, Shippers, Loaders, and Repair Providers
In a May 2026 broker hiring ruling, the U.S. Supreme Court held that federal trucking law did not preempt the state negligent-hiring claim against the freight broker because the statutory safety exception applied.
The Court did not decide whether the broker was actually negligent. A shipper, cargo loader, or repair provider may also be relevant when its own conduct, such as unsafe loading or negligent repair work, contributed to the collision.
How Much Insurance Can Apply to Truck Accident Claims?
South Carolina requires drivers to carry at least $25,000 in bodily injury coverage for one person, $50,000 for two or more people injured in the same crash, and $25,000 for property damage.
Commercial trucks operating across state lines may have much higher insurance requirements. Under 49 C.F.R. § 387.9, a for-hire carrier transporting nonhazardous property in a vehicle weighing 10,001 pounds or more must carry at least $750,000 in public liability coverage. Trucks carrying certain hazardous materials may be required to carry $1 million or $5 million.
These amounts are minimum requirements, not necessarily the total insurance available after a crash. The available coverage can depend on whether the truck operates within South Carolina or across state lines, the vehicle’s weight, the type of cargo, and whether other parties may also be responsible.
The Federal Safety Rules Truck Drivers Have to Follow
Commercial drivers follow state traffic laws, but many also operate under federal motor-carrier safety rules. Those rules can create records that help test what happened before and after a crash.
Driving Hours and Fatigue
Federal driving-hour rules generally allow a property-carrying driver to drive 11 hours after 10 consecutive hours off and prohibit driving after the 14th consecutive hour on duty. Except for qualifying short-haul drivers, a 30-minute interruption in driving is required after more than eight cumulative hours.
Electronic logs and supporting records can show when the driver was on duty, driving, or off duty. Conflicts between the log and dispatch, fuel, toll, or other records can be relevant to a fatigue claim.
Alcohol and Drug Testing After a Crash
Federal rules prohibit a commercial driver from performing safety-sensitive functions with an alcohol concentration of 0.04 or greater. Post-accident testing is required after a fatal crash regardless of a citation. After an injury requiring immediate treatment away from the scene or a tow-away crash, testing depends on whether the driver receives the qualifying moving-traffic citation.
Alcohol testing should occur as soon as practicable. If it is not completed within two hours, the employer must document why; attempts stop after eight hours. The controlled-substance testing window is 32 hours.
The Evidence in a Truck Case Runs on Different Timelines
A truck case can add electronic logging records, dispatch communications, driver qualification records, maintenance documents, cargo records, dashcam footage, and engine or telematics data to the evidence used in an ordinary car claim.
Federal rules require motor carriers to keep records of duty status and required supporting documents for at least six months. That six-month rule does not automatically govern every type of crash evidence. Video, engine data, and other electronic information may follow different retention systems or preservation obligations.
A written preservation demand can identify the records being requested before routine retention periods expire. South Carolina also recognizes a potential negative inference when critical evidence is not preserved. In Stokes v. Spartanburg Regional Medical Center, the Court of Appeals held that the jury should have received such an instruction after critical evidence was lost.
For truck accident claims, that makes early identification of ELD records, dispatch communications, available video, vehicle data, driver records, and maintenance evidence particularly important.
Will a Columbia Truck Accident Case Go to Federal Court?
Most Columbia truck accident cases can be filed in South Carolina state court, even when the truck driver or trucking company is based in another state. A case may qualify for federal court when the amount in dispute exceeds $75,000, and there is complete diversity, meaning the plaintiffs and defendants are citizens of different states.
Even then, removal to federal court is not always available. If a properly joined and served defendant is a South Carolina citizen, the defendant generally cannot remove the case to federal court based solely on diversity jurisdiction.
So, an out-of-state trucking company does not automatically mean a federal case. Where the lawsuit proceeds depends on who the parties are, where they are legally considered citizens, how much is being claimed, and whether the requirements for federal jurisdiction are met.
FAQs About Truck Accident Claims in SC
What if the truck driver was an independent owner-operator?
The lease and operating authority still matter. An authorized carrier lessee must have exclusive possession, control, and use of leased equipment and assume responsibility for its operation during the lease. But 49 C.F.R. § 376.12 says that rule does not by itself decide employee or independent-contractor status. The operating carrier’s name and USDOT number generally must appear on both sides.
What if cargo or debris fell off a truck and hit my car?
Federal cargo rules require loads to be secured against leaking, spilling, blowing, or falling. Cargo also cannot shift enough to impair stability or maneuverability. Depending on who loaded, secured, and controlled it, responsibility may extend beyond the driver or carrier.
Who can file truck accident claims when someone was killed?
A South Carolina wrongful death action is brought by or in the name of the deceased person’s executor or administrator. Recovery goes to the surviving spouse and children, then to the parents if there are none, and then to the heirs.
Can I get workers’ compensation and still sue the trucking company?
Yes, when the trucking company is a legally responsible third party rather than an employer or another party protected by workers’ compensation exclusivity. South Carolina law allows workers’ compensation benefits and a third-party action, while giving the compensation carrier a lien on the recovery. Section 42-1-560 also contains a one-year third-party-action rule and written-notice requirements before the claim can be assigned to the carrier.
Get Help With Truck Accident Claims in Columbia
A serious truck case should not stop at the driver’s insurance card and collision report. The operating carrier, policies, driving hours, post-accident testing, maintenance, cargo records, and electronic data can affect who is responsible and what proves the claim.
Reviewing that material can show whether a direct claim against the company is supported, whether federal rules apply, whether another business contributed, and whether federal court is possible. Those questions are worth resolving before records are lost or settlement discussions advance.
The Law Offices of Lori S. Murray represents people injured in motor-vehicle crashes, including commercial truck accidents. Lori Murray’s background includes insurance defense and service as an Assistant Solicitor in Richland County. To discuss truck accident claims after a serious Columbia area crash, call (803) 779-4472 for a free consultation.
This article is general information about South Carolina and federal law, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Talk to a South Carolina attorney about the facts of your own crash.

